Draughon v. Cobblestone Homeowners Ass'n of Clayton, Inc., 789 S.E.2d 746, 249 N.C. App. 245 (2016)

Sept. 6, 2016 · Court of Appeals of North Carolina · No. COA15–1280; No. COA15–1302; No. COA15–1303; No. COA15–1282
789 S.E.2d 746, 249 N.C. App. 245
Dennis DRAUGHON and Megan Draughon, Plaintiffs, v. COBBLESTONE HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION OF CLAYTON, INC., a North Carolina non-profit corporation, Defendant. Robert Sain and Jennifer Sain, Plaintiffs, v. Cobblestone Homeowners Association of Clayton, Inc., a North Carolina non-profit corporation, Defendant. Vincent Franks, Jr., Plaintiff, v. Cobblestone Homeowners Association of Clayton, Inc., a North Carolina non-profit corporation, Defendant. Frank Christopher, Plaintiff, v. Cobblestone Homeowners Association of Clayton, Inc., a North Carolina non-profit corporation, Defendant.

Dennis DRAUGHON and Megan Draughon, Plaintiffs,
v.
COBBLESTONE HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION OF CLAYTON, INC., a North Carolina non-profit corporation, Defendant.

Robert Sain and Jennifer Sain, Plaintiffs,
v.
Cobblestone Homeowners Association of Clayton, Inc., a North Carolina non-profit corporation, Defendant.

Vincent Franks, Jr., Plaintiff,
v.
Cobblestone Homeowners Association of Clayton, Inc., a North Carolina non-profit corporation, Defendant.

Frank Christopher, Plaintiff,
v.
Cobblestone Homeowners Association of Clayton, Inc., a North Carolina non-profit corporation, Defendant.

No. COA15-1280
No. COA15-1302
No. COA15-1303
No. COA15-1282

Court of Appeals of North Carolina.

Filed: September 6, 2016

Spence & Spence, P.A., Smithfield, by Robert A. Spence, Jr., for Plaintiff-Appellee Frank Christopher.

No briefs filed for other Plaintiffs-Appellees.

*747Jordan Price Wall Gray Jones & Carlton, Raleigh, by J. Matthew Waters and Hope Derby Carmichael, for Defendant-Appellant.

McGEE, Chief Judge.

*246These cases are companion cases to Sanchez v. Cobblestone , COA15-1281, filed contemporaneously with these opinions. Sanchez includes the facts and analysis relevant to resolution of the cases consolidated in this opinion: COA15-1280, COA15-1282, COA15-1302, and COA15-1303. For the reasons stated in the majority opinion in Sanchez , we affirm.

AFFIRMED.

Judge HUNTER, JR. concurs.

Judge DILLON dissents with separate opinion.

DILLON, Judge, dissenting.

These are companion cases to Sanchez v. Cobblestone , COA15-1281. For the reasons fully stated in my dissenting opinion in Sanchez , I respectfully dissent.