State v. Suddreth, 230 N.C. 754 (1949)

Oct. 19, 1949 · Supreme Court of North Carolina
230 N.C. 754

STATE v. TOM SUDDRETH.

(Filed 19 October, 1949.)

Criminal Xiaw § 57b—

No appeal lies from tlie discretionary refusal of the Superior Court of a motion for a new trial on account of newly discovered evidence.

Appeal by defendant from Shuford, Special Judge, at Special May Term, 1949, of Caldwell.

Criminal prosecution upon a bill of indictment charging defendant with tbe murder of one Harry Crisp, Jr.

Verdict: Guilty of manslaughter.

Judgment pronounced at November Term, 1948, of Superior Court of Caldwell County.

On appeal to Supreme Court at Spring Term, 1949, no error was found, — see ante, 239, 52 S.E. 2d 924. Thereafter at Special May Term, 1949, of Superior Court of said county, defendant filed motion for a new trial on account of newly discovered evidence,- — supporting same by certain affidavits. Tbe judge presiding, after bearing tbe affidavits offered by defendant and tbe argument of bis counsel, denied tbe motion in bis discretion.

From order in accordance therewith defendant appeals to Supreme Court, and assigns error.

Attorney-General McMullan and Assistant Attorney-General Bruton for the State.

W. U. Strickland and Max C. Wilson for defendant, appellant.