Muzzell v. Lee, 23 N.C. 411, 1 Ired. 411 (1841)

June 1841 · Supreme Court of North Carolina
23 N.C. 411, 1 Ired. 411

WILLIAM A MUZZELL vs. THOMAS L. LEE.

Upon what facts a certiorari will be refused, when the appellant from the Superior Court did not bring up his appeal.

The appeal in this case, which was allowed at Spring Term, 1841, of Caswell Superior Court of Law, not having been brought up within the time prescribed by law, James T. Morehead, counsel for the plaintiff, moved for a certiorari, to bring up the proceedings on the following affidavits, to-wit:

*412John. K. Graves maketh oath, that he is Clerk of the Su~ Pe™r Court of Law of the County of Caswell, that the plaintiff, in the above stated case, resides out of this State* that one of his counsel, to-wit, William A. Graham, had to leave immediately after Court, for Washington City, and that the other, to-wit, James T. Morehead, lives at the distance of forty miles ; that the appeal bond was filed at the Court where the appeal was granted; that express directions were given by counsel for sending up the case, and the Clerk promised to do so. And this affiant further states, that the transcript in the case was made out in time to reach Raleigh in the time required by law for filing appeals.

(Subscribed and sworn to in due form of law.)

Paul A Harrison maketh oath, that he is Clerk of the Court of Pleas and Quarter Sessions of the County of Caswell; that he was at the Superior Court of Law held for said county, at May Term, 1841, and assisted the Clerk of the said Superior Court in the discharge of his duties in Court; that upon the rise of Court, (after the trial of the above stated cause, and the appeal to the Supreme Court was granted,) he was spoken to by James T. Morehead, Esquire, one of the counsel for the appellant, William A. Muzzell, to aid the Clerk in making out the transcript to go to the Supreme Court, and was moreover further requested by the said counsel, to say to the Clerk, that he (the counsel) wished the transcript to be made out as soon as he could do so, and forwarded on to the Supreme Court. This affiant further states that the plaintiff (the appellant,) resides beyond the limits of this State; and that one of his counsel is a United States Senator, and had to leave shortly after Court for Washington City, and that the other resides at the distance of forty miles ; that an appeal bond was filed at Court, when the appeal was granted, and that express directions were given by counsel for sending up the case.

(Subscribed and sworn to.)

Edmund B. Freeman makes oath, that the record of the suit of William A. Muzzell, adm’r. vs. Thomas L. Lee, Sheriff, reached his office, as he believes, on Tuesday morning, *41322d June, and (if he is not mistaken in this,) it must have reached the post office in the City, the evening before. fiant has mislaid the envelope which came around the said record, and therefore he cannot state at what time the said record was mailed. He says further, that although he believes the said record reached the Clerk’s office on Tuesday morning, it might have been Wednesday the 23d of June.— He is certain it was not later than Tuesday or Wednesday.

(Subscribed and sworn to.)

Per Curiam,

The certiorari cannot be granted.*