S.K. Condo. II Ass'n, Inc. v. NS/Cse Siesta Key, LLC, 275 So. 3d 579 (2019)

June 7, 2019 · District Court of Appeal of Florida, Second District · Case No. 2D18-1403
275 So. 3d 579
S.K. CONDOMINIUM II ASSOCIATION, INC. and SKBP, LLC, Appellants, v. NS/CSE SIESTA KEY, LLC, S.K. Condominium Association, Inc., Kris A. Jaenicke, Ann J. Jaenicke, Robert Alan Grant, Kimberly Sue Grant, Gary D. Johnson, as Trustee or Successor Trustee of the Gary D. Johnson Revocable Living Trust Dated 10/18/2004, as Amended, Becky P. Pomfret, Kirk F. Malcolm, Daniel C. Kates, as Trustee of the Daniel C. Kates Trust Dated September 6, 1984, as amended, Michael I. Yarymovych, Roxolana A. Yarymovych, Deering Crescent Residence, LLC, Donald S. Dazen, Karolyn Dazen, Barry S. Farah, Christopher A. Saco, Paula B. Saco, Karen T. Brown, as Trustee of the Karen T. Brown Trust Dated 7/18/2002, Robert B. Brown, as Trustee of the Robert B. Brown Trust #96 Dated 4/30/1996, Bruce J. Cusenz, Paul V. Caputo, Sr., as Trustee of the Cindy J. Caputo 2008 Trust, Vitia dated June 18, 2008, Richard J. Holleman, as Trustee under the Holleman Family Living Trust, Dated May 15, 2000, Mary Lee-Holleman, as Trustee under the Holleman Family Living Trust, Dated May 15, 2000, Keith A. Cheesman, As Trustee of the Mary Patrice Cheesman Revocable Trust Agreement, Mary Patrice Cheesman, as Trustee of the Mary Patrice Cheesman Revocable Trust Agreement, John J. Martin, Molly Resnik, Roger Ervin Kahler, Connie Lucile Kahler, Aaron Andrew Litersky, Stacy Allison Litersky, Brad Ervin Kahler, Jenna Brooks Kahler, George Steven Webster, as Trustee under that certain Revocable Trust Agreement dated April 24, 2012, Sandra A. Schwalbach, as Trustee of the Sandra A. Schwalbach Revocable Trust Declaration, Dave P. Lima, Gerwais L. Piecuch, as Trustee of the Gerwais L. Piecuch and Joyce D. Piecuch Revocable Trust U/AJD April 17, 2014, Joyce D. Piecuch, as Trustee of the Gerwais L. Piecuch and Joyce D. Piecuch Revocable Trust U/AJD April 17, 2014, Paul J. Mason, Deborah L. Mason, Joseph Vezza, Giovanna Vezza, S J Siesta Key, LLC, Harold L. Solomon, Valerie N. Solomon, Carole J. Niederpruem, as Trustee of the Carol J. Niederpruem Trust Agreement dated February 15, 2000, as restated, Terry Butler, Kristina L. Butler, Ann G. Dorr, Susan F. Hillel, Pavel Hillel, Travis W. King, as Trustee of the Travis W. King Revocable Living Trust Agreement, Patricia A. King, as Trustee of the Patricia A. King Revocable Living Trust Agreement dated June 27, 2000, William V. Destasio, Nancy S. Destasio, Jonathan Lee Singer, Cg Siesta Key LLC, Detlef Friedrich Zimmerman, Katherine Ella Zimmerman, John R. Meils, Brenda S. Meils, Alan Schreiber, Michele Clements-Schreiber, Craig Robert Kingston, Brooke Stewart Kingston, Robert Kaplan, Anne Kaplan, Jack Kaplan, Marian Kaplan, Chris J. Savona, Patricia J. Nakfoor, Nancy Wallace, David A. Kane, Ann J. Kane, Craig A. Hurst, Lyn M. Unsworth, W. Barry Gilbert, Julene Gilbert, Marc Julius, Karen E. Julius, Steven J. Engelmyer, Lisa B. Wershaw, Mark Hamann, Cynthia Pokrzywa, B. Walter Rosen, Marcia F. Rosen, William F. McGovern, Barbara H. McGovern, Charles E. Girk, as Directing Trustee of the Second Amendment and Restatement of the Donna M. Girk Revocable Trust Agreement dated April 12, 1993, David A. Eshman, Julie W. Eshman, Rydzik Rentals, Thomas K. Hughes, Michelle E. Hughes, William F. McNamara, Lorraine R. McNamara, James W. Franklin, Jr., Tiki Key LLC, Ann M. Mallouk, John M. Hunter, Judith M. Hunter, Alan B. Grindal, Gladys E. Grindal, Jose F. Dematos, Jr., Stacie M. Dematos, David S. Taylor, Marsha H. Taylor, Joseph B. Culloo, Jr., Regina A. Culloo, Joyce A. Phillips, as Trustee of the Joyce A. Phillips Family Trust under agreement dated August 12, 2003, Eric Edward Fehling, Rimma Dianna Fehling, Kyle Blaine Ahlfinger, as Trustee of the Ahlfinger Family Trust, dated April 25, 2011, Sandra Collier Ahlfinger, as Trustee of the Ahlfinger Family Trust, dated April 25, 2011, Milton B. Grin, Trudi R. Grin, Robert Schaal, Barbara A. Schaal, Daryl Schaal, Wendy Schaal, Manish Jain, Renee Page, Floyd Stephen Chitty, as Co-Trustee of the Chitty Family Living Trust dated March 23, 2015, Jo Ann Chitty, as Co-Trustee of the Chitty Family Living Trust dated March 23, 2015, Ross M. Cellino, Jr., Anna Marie Cellino, Richard A. Wilson, Stephanie Wilson, and Bhesania Research/CardioLab Inc., Appellees.

S.K. CONDOMINIUM II ASSOCIATION, INC. and SKBP, LLC, Appellants,
v.
NS/CSE SIESTA KEY, LLC, S.K. Condominium Association, Inc., Kris A. Jaenicke, Ann J. Jaenicke, Robert Alan Grant, Kimberly Sue Grant, Gary D. Johnson, as Trustee or Successor Trustee of the Gary D. Johnson Revocable Living Trust Dated 10/18/2004, as Amended, Becky P. Pomfret, Kirk F. Malcolm, Daniel C. Kates, as Trustee of the Daniel C. Kates Trust Dated September 6, 1984, as amended, Michael I. Yarymovych, Roxolana A. Yarymovych, Deering Crescent Residence, LLC, Donald S. Dazen, Karolyn Dazen, Barry S. Farah, Christopher A. Saco, Paula B. Saco, Karen T. Brown, as Trustee of the Karen T. Brown Trust Dated 7/18/2002, Robert B. Brown, as Trustee of the Robert B. Brown Trust #96 Dated 4/30/1996, Bruce J. Cusenz, Paul V. Caputo, Sr., as Trustee of the Cindy J. Caputo 2008 Trust, Vitia dated June 18, 2008, Richard J. Holleman, as Trustee under the Holleman Family Living Trust, Dated May 15, 2000, Mary Lee-Holleman, as Trustee under the Holleman Family Living Trust, Dated May 15, 2000, Keith A. Cheesman, As Trustee of the Mary Patrice Cheesman Revocable Trust Agreement, Mary Patrice Cheesman, as Trustee of the Mary Patrice Cheesman Revocable Trust Agreement, John J. Martin, Molly Resnik, Roger Ervin Kahler, Connie Lucile Kahler, Aaron Andrew Litersky, Stacy Allison Litersky, Brad Ervin Kahler, Jenna Brooks Kahler, George Steven Webster, as Trustee under that certain Revocable Trust Agreement dated April 24, 2012, Sandra A. Schwalbach, as Trustee of the Sandra A. Schwalbach Revocable Trust Declaration, Dave P. Lima, Gerwais L. Piecuch, as Trustee of the Gerwais L. Piecuch and Joyce D. Piecuch Revocable Trust U/AJD April 17, 2014, Joyce D. Piecuch, as Trustee of the Gerwais L. Piecuch and Joyce D. Piecuch Revocable Trust U/AJD April 17, 2014, Paul J. Mason, Deborah L. Mason, Joseph Vezza, Giovanna Vezza, S J Siesta Key, LLC, Harold L. Solomon, Valerie N. Solomon, Carole J. Niederpruem, as Trustee of the Carol J. Niederpruem Trust Agreement dated February 15, 2000, as restated, Terry Butler, Kristina L. Butler, Ann G. Dorr, Susan F. Hillel, Pavel Hillel, Travis W. King, as Trustee of the Travis W. King Revocable Living Trust Agreement, Patricia A. King, as Trustee of the Patricia A. King Revocable Living Trust Agreement dated June 27, 2000, William V. Destasio, Nancy S. Destasio, Jonathan Lee Singer, Cg Siesta Key LLC, Detlef Friedrich Zimmerman, Katherine Ella Zimmerman, John R. Meils, Brenda S. Meils, Alan Schreiber, Michele Clements-Schreiber, Craig Robert Kingston, Brooke Stewart Kingston, Robert Kaplan, Anne Kaplan, Jack Kaplan, Marian Kaplan, Chris J. Savona, Patricia J. Nakfoor, Nancy Wallace, David A. Kane, Ann J. Kane, Craig A. Hurst, Lyn M. Unsworth, W. Barry Gilbert, Julene Gilbert, Marc Julius, Karen E. Julius, Steven J. Engelmyer, Lisa B. Wershaw, Mark Hamann, Cynthia Pokrzywa, B. Walter Rosen, Marcia F. Rosen, William F. McGovern, Barbara H. McGovern, Charles E. Girk, as Directing Trustee of the Second Amendment and Restatement of the Donna M. Girk Revocable Trust Agreement dated April 12, 1993, David A. Eshman, Julie W. Eshman, Rydzik Rentals, Thomas K. Hughes, Michelle E. Hughes, William F. McNamara, Lorraine R. McNamara, James W. Franklin, Jr., Tiki Key LLC, Ann M. Mallouk, John M. Hunter, Judith M. Hunter, Alan B. Grindal, Gladys E. Grindal, Jose F. Dematos, Jr., Stacie M. Dematos, David S. Taylor, Marsha H. Taylor, Joseph B. Culloo, Jr., Regina A. Culloo, Joyce A. Phillips, as Trustee of the Joyce A. Phillips Family Trust under agreement dated August 12, 2003, Eric Edward Fehling, Rimma Dianna Fehling, Kyle Blaine Ahlfinger, as Trustee of the Ahlfinger Family Trust, dated April 25, 2011, Sandra Collier Ahlfinger, as Trustee of the Ahlfinger Family Trust, dated April 25, 2011, Milton B. Grin, Trudi R. Grin, Robert Schaal, Barbara A. Schaal, Daryl Schaal, Wendy Schaal, Manish Jain, Renee Page, Floyd Stephen Chitty, as Co-Trustee of the Chitty Family Living Trust dated March 23, 2015, Jo Ann Chitty, as Co-Trustee of the Chitty Family Living Trust dated March 23, 2015, Ross M. Cellino, Jr., Anna Marie Cellino, Richard A. Wilson, Stephanie Wilson, and Bhesania Research/CardioLab Inc., Appellees.

Case No. 2D18-1403

District Court of Appeal of Florida, Second District.

Opinion filed June 7, 2019

DECISION WITHOUT PUBLISHED OPINION

Affirmed.